THE HUNLEY NEWSLETTER

 
by George W. Penington  -  Editor
 FOR SUBSCRIBERS

MAY 2006 Issue #64CHARLESTON'S NAVAL HISTORY
IN THIS ISSUE: 

Contents:
WELCOME TO THE NEW HUNLEY NEWSLETTER
FROM THE HUNLEY STORE
Follow Up from Newsletter 62 about  the Submarine Explorer
HISTORIC FIND-Disease Called
"EYEdiscluberdum"
IN CASE YOU MISSED IT:
tour PLANNED by bus of Confederate Naval sites
FOLLOW UP ON THE HUNLEY CREW
Battle of Secessionville June 17 2006
E-MAIL AND GUEST BOOK SELECTIONS
The Hunley - Will She Sink Again?
H.L. Hunley Experience IN MYRTLE BEACH CLOSED
What the STATE PAPER found
How senator steers sub under radar
Hunley key moments
no market study

Tours of the Hunley

TO OUR SUBSCRIBERS
TO CANCEL RECEIVING THIS NEWSLETTER
 

WELCOME TO THE NEW HUNLEY NEWSLETTER

ALL issues are dedicated  to the brave and
honorable Men of the Hunley and  to the
Subscribers and Contributors to
each issue, particularly to the CSS H L HUNLEY
CLUB and The Post and Courier, and The State Paper.
   "As long as there are controversies, I have fodder for the Newsletters"  ENJOY


ANOTHER SPECIAL THANKS TO TWO MORE GREAT PEOPLE WHO SENT A DONATION LAST MONTH - YOU KNOW WHO YOU ARE - IT MEANS A LOT TO ME!!


Follow Up from Newsletter 62 about  the Submarine Explorer 
EARLY SUBMARINE DISCOVERY

The Secret of the Pearl Islands
By
Sven Röbel

The Pearl Island "Survivors" were in the 'hood situated in the Gulf of Panama about 50 miles southeast of Panama City, this archipelago comprises about 183 islands. Many of these are tiny and largely unexplored, but in general, the islands are characterized by rich soil, lush foliage and abundant wildlife. EXILE ISLAND was one of these.

 For the past 137 years, a mysterious wreck has emerged at low tide each day on a beach off the coast of Panama. Researchers now know that it's the presumed lost "Sub Marine Explorer," one of the world's first submarines and a vessel that would ultimately kill its German inventor.

The tower was the first thing Jim Delgado saw. Inch by inch, it emerged from the deep-green surf of the Pacific Ocean -- an encrusted piece of black metal covered with barnacles, rust and seaweed, a ghostly apparition slowly rising from the sea.

Delgado was sitting on the roots of an ancient palmetto tree, staring at the water as if transfixed. Aside from the hermit crabs digging in the sand at his feet and the brown pelicans screeching in the treetops, Delgado was alone -- the only human being on this godforsaken island known as San Telmo, somewhere southeast of Panama City.

THE 19TH CENTURY SUBMARINE
Low tide came slowly and sluggishly, eventually exposing the mysterious rust-eaten wreck a fisherman had described to Delgado. The man believed it was a Japanese submarine that had been on a mission to attack ships near the Panama Canal during World War II, only to fall prey to the treacherous waters of the Pearl Archipelago.

But the more the tide retreated, the more Delgado -- director of the renowned Vancouver Maritime Museum -- was convinced that the fisherman's story couldn't possibly be true. This thing appearing before his eyes had to be older, much older.

The design reminded the scientist of an "iron cigar," and he instinctively thought of the "Nautilus," that legendary underwater vessel author Jules Verne described in his novel "20,000 Leagues Under the Sea." Delgado had devoured the book as a young boy.


THE NAUTILUS FROM THE HUNLEY STORE

But could something like this be possible? Delgado was mesmerized. Years ago, working as a marine archaeologist, he had recovered the wreck of the "General Harrison," a ship from the days of the California gold rush, from San Francisco Bay. He was also involved in the raising of the "H.L. Hunley" from the harbor entrance at Charleston, South Carolina -- the first submarine ever to sink an enemy ship, during the American Civil War in 1864.

And now, on this isolated beach on a tropical island -- during his vacation, no less -- he had apparently happened upon the most spectacular find of his career.

Without any equipment, and wearing nothing but boxer shorts, Delgado swam out to the mysterious wreck. He cursed when he scraped his left leg on the sharp-edged metal -- and because he didn't have a measuring tape to document the object's exact dimensions.

You may recall that Judge Sol Blatt ordered Cussler's legal team to remove several objectionable parts of a legal filling against Lee Spence because it  appeared to be included solely to embarrass Spence. The part ordered removed was  Spence's description of diving for the Hunley clad in his underwear  and that it was meant to bring ridicule.

The size, shape and condition of the chambers corresponded to none of the vessels he was familiar with -- and Delgado thought he knew just about everything that had ever floated. But this craft's technology seemed much more modern that that of the "Hunley." The shape of the hull was more reminiscent of the fantasy forms he'd seen in old science fiction books. Why on earth, he wondered, had he never heard about this vessel?

When Delgado heard the sound of the approaching rubber dinghy that had come to take him back to his cruise ship, he quickly took a few shots with his camera -- hardly able to believe his luck at having decided to pass on the dull bird-watching outing the other passengers had taken. His few hours on this remote island had truly been worth it.

Back to the Table of Contents

Historic find

EDITOR'S NOTE:: Marine Archaeologist, writers, and explorers have amongst themselves a common disease called "EYEdiscluberdum" which actually means "I discovered what the hell it was"  In this case many of the locals and visitors crawled, swam around and took pictures of this strange looking sub.  It was even on several local tour boat agendas.With this kind of reasoning you could say "I discovered the Sub Marine Explorer on the Internet"

That was five years ago, and by now it's become clear that Delgado made a sensational historic find. He discovered the lost "Sub Marine Explorer," one of the world's first functioning underwater boats, designed by a brilliant German engineer whose invention eventually brought him an agonizing death.

DER SPIEGEL
A look at the workings of the submarine.
 

 

 

 

 

The well-preserved wreck off the shores of San Telmo offers an unprecedented glimpse into the maritime past. Even though the beginnings of manned underwater vessels aren't so distant, the pioneer days of submarines remain filled with unanswered questions. Old construction plans often diverge from the actual designs, and many boats were either lost or destroyed. In some cases it remains unclear as to exactly how -- and whether -- the vehicles actually worked.

The San Telmo discovery could provide answers to many questions about the first submarines. Some of Delgado's colleagues believe that the wreck in the Pacific is a unique example of a handful of submarine prototypes that have remained preserved. They are craft in which daring men -- essentially the Space Shuttle pilots of their age -- ventured into the unknown world beneath the ocean's surface in the 19th century. Only five diving machines from the years before 1870 have survived the ravages of time:

  •  The "Brandtaucher" designed by German inventor Wilhelm Bauer, now in a museum in Dresden.
     

    Brandtaucher was recovered in 1887 and is now on display in Dresden, Germany.  Picture from  PBS.org
    Support Your Local PBS Station

     

  • A nameless submarine used by the Confederates in 1862, during the American Civil War, now on display in New Orleans.

  •  
  • The "H.L. Hunley," built in 1863 and currently being restored in Charleston, South Carolina.
     
  • The "Intelligent Whale," a submarine built in 1866 and now in a New Jersey museum.
     
  • And the "Sub Marine Explorer" off the coast of San Telmo in the Pacific, built in 1865.
  • The "Explorer" marks a high point in maritime engineering, but also a tragic one. Equipped with a cleverly designed system of ballast chambers and a compressed air tank that allowed for pressure compensation, it also had two hatches beneath the hull enabling divers to exit the craft underwater. But about 130 years ago, when the vessel was being used to collect oysters and pearls from the ocean floor off the coast of Panama, the condition known as "the bends," or decompression sickness, was largely unknown. The condition can cause an agonizing death when divers rise to the surface from deep water too quickly. Technical progress had fatally outpaced medical science, costing the inventor and team of the "Explorer" their health and their lives.

    But on the evening following his discovery, as he sat excitedly in the dining room of his cruise ship, Delgado had no idea of the tragedies that must have transpired in this iron coffin in the Pacific's pearl beds. Instead, he couldn't stop describing the details of the strange wreck to his wife Ann.

    Back home in Vancouver, the scientist had the pictures he took on San Telmo developed and promptly e-mailed the images -- together with a description and a request for further information -- to colleagues around the world.

    One man, Richard Wills, an expert on American Civil War submarines, wrote back to inform Delgado that his data were a perfect match to a description Wills had discovered in a scientific article from 1902. The piece even included a precise drawing of the largely unknown diving device. This couldn't possibly be a coincidence -- the vessel had to be the "Sub Marine Explorer."

    Little known inventor

    Sven Röbel
    Inside Kroehl's craft.
    Little was known at the time about the man who designed the craft, a German inventor named Julius H. Kroehl who had emigrated to the United States. He built an iron fire watchtower in Harlem in 1865 and was then hired by the New York magistrate to demolish -- unsuccessfully, as it turned out -- a reef that obstructed shipping in the East River. But how did the mysterious German hit upon the idea of designing such a progressive diving ship? Delgado decided to get to the bottom of the story. A search through historical archives revealed that the "Sub Marine Explorer" last belonged to an outfit called the Pacific Pearl Company, which planned to dig for oysters off the coast of Panama in the 1860s.

    As far back as the days of the Conquistadors, divers had been digging up treasures from the depths of the "Archipiélago de las Perlas." Black slaves had once fished the famed "La Peregrina" pearl -- a magnificent, softly shimmering 50-carat jewel -- from the waters of the archipelago. The shells also held the promise of fortune, offering wealth in the form of mother-of-pearl, a highly sought-after luxury material used in the fashion of the day.

    According to old business records, one of the partners in the company with offices near New York's Wall Street was a certain W.H. Tiffany, apparently a member of the eponymous jewelry and lamp dynasty.

    The story was becoming more and more fascinating, and after making two more trips to San Telmo in 2002 and 2004, Delgado had finally collected enough material to justify launching an expedition to delve into the final secrets of the "Explorer" and its inventor.


    tour PLANNED by bus of Confederate Naval sites


    I am planning a one week tour by bus of Confederate

    Naval sites and museums from Wilmington (and Kinston), NC to Charleston, SC; Savannah, GA; Columbus, GA; and ending in Mobile, AL. The cost estimates per person are $1500 to $2000 to include transportation, lodging, meals, and admissions. Participants will have to get to Wilmington and home from Mobile. If enough persons sign up I can line it up for this October, otherwise it will be October 2007.

     Anyone interested please contact me by return e-mail

    at cokerre@yahoo.com. Input welcome.

     PC Coker/Charleston

    csshlhunley@yahoogroups.com

     


    Back to the Table of Contents
     

    FOLLOW UP ON THE HUNLEY CREW



    An x-ray shows the remains of a crew member's foot inside of a
    shoe. Forensic experts used modern technology to identify the
    eight crew members of the Hunley. The National Geographic
    Expeditions Council helped fund the raising of the Hunley and
    the analysis of the materials found inside.

    For over a century historians have puzzled over the mystery of
    what happened the night the Civil War submarine H.L. Hunley
    disappeared in 1864. Sealed inside the time capsule were the
    remains of the crew (above), and as many historians hoped some
    answers to over a century’s worth of lingering questions.

    Once all of the clay was applied to the reconstruction (above),
    hair and other facial features were added. (See next four images.)


    A forensic artist attempted to give faces to the Hunley crew.
    Markers indicating depth of flesh at different points were placed
    on a cast of a skull (left). Then, clay was used to sculpt a face
    using the markers as a guide (right).

    Arnold Becker (left) was foreign-born, but experts do not know
    exactly where he was from. Becker was in charge of operating
    the air circulation system that enabled the crew to breathe on
    the H.L. Hunley. George Dixon (right) was the Hunley’s commander.
    He was in charge of navigating the submarine and firing the
    explosive weapon.

    Joseph Ridgaway (left) was second-in-command of the H.L.
    Hunley and was born in Talbot County, Maryland. Experts
    were unable to determine the first name of Lumpkin (right).
    However, they were able to determine that he was one of
    the oldest crewmen on board.

    Miller (left) also has an unknown first name. He was from Europe
    and had only been in the United States for a short amount of time
    before joining the H.L. Hunley crew. Frank Collins (right) was born
    in Virginia and was the largest crewman on board the Hunley.

    J.F. Carlsen (left) was the newest member of the H.L. Hunley's
    crew when it sank. He was only 20 to 23 years old. James A. Wicks
    (right) was born in North Carolina around 1819. He was one of
    only three Hunley crewmen, along with Joseph Ridgaway and
    Frank Collins, born in the South.

    top 
    Battle of Secessionville June 17 2006
     

    Civil War Fort ceremony to mark 1862 Battle of Secessionville June 17  Press Release:
     

    Amid the roar of cannon fire Saturday, June 17, South Carolinians at Fort Lamar in Charleston will commemorate the Battle of Secessionville, one of the Palmetto State’s most important Civil War battles that helped keep the port of Charleston out of Yankee hands.

    Ceremonies to commemorate the 144th anniversary of the Battle of Secessionville will begin at 10 a.m. Saturday, June 17. Everyone is welcome.

    DNR Media Contacts:
    Columbia -
    Brett Witt (803) 734-3815
    Clemson -
    Greg Lucas (864) 654-1671, ext.22
    Charleston -
    Anna Martin (843) 953-3367
    Spokesman -
    Mike Willis (803) 734-4133
    After Hours Radio Room - (803) 955-4000

     

    Historians consider Fort Lamar and the Battle of Secessionville the second-most important Civil War battleground in the state after Fort Sumter, where the war began. Heritage Trust, a part of the S.C. Department of Natural Resources (DNR) Habitat Protection Section, acquired the 13.5-acre Fort Lamar Heritage Preserve in 1996. The fort is south of Charleston on James Island.

    The preserve includes ramparts from Fort Lamar, a battery that helped repel Union troops during the Battle of Secessionville on June 16, 1862. A Union force of 3,500 men attacked the fort but was turned back three times by 1,250 Confederate soldiers.

     http://www.sctrails.net/trails/MAPS/FortLamarHP%20map.html

    Description: Before you begin this very short, easy-walking, historic trail, pick up a self-guided tour brochure from the kiosk near the Battle of Secessionville Monument. Walk toward the trail sign and follow the numbered markers that correspond with the brochure descriptions of what once stood in those areas. Fort Lamar, originally known as Tower Battery because of its 75-foot observation tower, was renamed for Colonel Thomas G. Lamar who commanded Confederate troops at the fort during the battle of Secessionville in 1862. After winding through open woods you will reach a short loop where you can return the way you came. From the parking area, you can also walk a short spur between the post and rail fence to remnants of earthworks that are sheltered beneath the sprawling oak trees. Watch for birds, snakes, and other wildlife.

    Use caution as you walk from the parking area through the right-hand gate and across the road to the trail. Insect repellent is recommended during warm months. No facilities are available. The houses around the site are private residences.

    Length: .2 mile one-way (including spur to point #6).

    Fees: No fee.

    Directions: From Charleston, drive west on US 17. At the intersection of US 17 South and SC 171/SC 700, drive south on SC 171. Drive 5.4 miles and turn left onto Grimball Road Extension. Drive .5 mile to the sign for Ft. Lamar Heritage Preserve and bear right onto Old Military Road. Drive .3 mile and turn left at the Ft. Lamar sign. Drive .8 mile and turn left into either gate for the parking area.

    Hours: Daily, dawn to dusk.

    Camping: No camping.

    Information: DNR Heritage Trust Program, P.O. Box 167, Columbia, SC, 29202, 803-734-3886.

    Description

    Fort Lamar HP - Trail Map

    They call it hallowed ground - a spiritual place where history, steeped in the marshes and forest, comes alive with every step along the trail.

    Located on 14 acres in Charleston County, Fort Lamar Heritage Preserve has been documented as the 2nd most important Civil War site in the state. Thousands of people visit Fort Lamar Heritage Preserve on James Island throughout the year, and annually on the closest weekend to June 16, many attend a commemoration at the preserve to observe the Battle of Secessionville. There, on June 16, 1862, Confederates, outnumbered three to one, defeated Federal soldiers in a fierce battle that saved Charleston and set the stage for three more years of fighting in the Civil War. Tower Battery, as Fort Lamar was initially called, was manned and being completed by the 1st South Carolina Artillery, commanded by Col. Thomas G. Lamar. The battery was completed in the spring of 1864 and named Fort Lamar in his memory. The battle began at 4 a.m., with 3,500 Federal troops attacking 1,250 Confederate troops at Tower Battery. But the Federal troops could not cross the marsh and got stuck in the pluff mud. By the time they retreated three hours later, Federal casualties included 107 killed, 487 wounded, and 89 missing. On the Confederate side, 54 killed, 144 wounded and 8 captured or missing.

    The previous Cultural Preserve Manager, Jon Rood, says that many historians consider the battle the "Union's Gettysburg" because it was realized that the war would not be over as early as projected. Some, like Sen. Glenn McConnell, say it is the most significant land battle of the Civil War in South Carolina.

    Hikers can get information at the kiosk in the parking lot for the self-guided trail, about a half-hour easy stroll. "You can stand inside the fort and you are standing in a cradle of history," McConnell says. "You can look out at the marshlands and very quickly imagine what went on there. You can experience the silence and the sounds of nature."

    People who visit the preserve revere it as hallowed ground, Rood says.

    Barry Gooch, who has taken part in the reenactments for the past three years, says they are a memorial service for both sides. "We're all pretty spiritual about this, and have respect for those who went before us," he says.

    Many stories still are recounted, like that of the Campbells, Scottish brothers who fought that day on opposing sides. They never encountered each other and both survived the war. Another is that of a Confederate officer whose slave died fetching his pistols. The officer also died that day. They are buried side by side.

    Gooch, like others, also visits the preserve during the year because of a sense of peace, tranquility and connectedness. "The most special part is that people thought enough about this place to preserve it," Gooch says.

    None of the trees are older than the battle, fought on farm land. Now, there are towering live oaks, yaupon hollies, bay berries and pines. Salt marsh life abounds, as well as all sorts of birds, including red tail hawks.

    Baxter Bragg, who lives about a block away, is the official "provost" of the preserve and one of the volunteers who visits daily to help maintain the grounds. Bragg says a favorite time is at dawn, with the sun rising over the slough and the first birds are flitting and singing. Then, "it's just like going to church."


     

     

    E-MAIL AND GUEST BOOK SELECTIONS

     

    Dear George:

              Recent articles on Senator McConnell and the Hunley Commission, although excellent, have missed several important and salient facts.

              Article 1, Section 8 of South Carolina’s constitution states: In the government of this State, the legislative, executive, and judicial powers of the government shall be forever separate and distinct from each other, and no person or persons exercising the functions of one of said departments shall assume or discharge the duties of any other.

              However, this has not been followed in the case of the Hunley Commission. It is not technically a commission. By law, all commissions report annually to the Secretary of State. The Hunley Commission never has. Attorney General McMasters has opined and the very language of its creation say that the Hunley Commission is a committee of the General Assembly. With its mandatory makeup of one-third of its membership appointed from the House and one-third from the Senate, the “Commission” is clearly meant to be controlled by the General Assembly (i.e. the Legislative Department) not the Executive Department. Section 54-7-100 of the South Carolina Code, gives the “Commission” the exclusive right, with respect to the Hunley, to assume the duties and responsibilities of the State Archaeologist and the Institute of Archaeology & Anthropology, (both offices of the Executive Department) as listed under Article 5, Chapter 7, of Title 54.

              Section 23 makes each section of the constitution mandatory, not arbitrary. It prevents anyone, from falsely claiming that the “Commission's” violation of Section 8 is minor, or unimportant, or merely technical and/or somehow justified.

              Therefore it should be clear to the Governor and the State's judiciary, that the Hunley Commission exists and operates in direct violation of Sections 8 and 23 of our constitution, and is unconstitutional. The measure of their credibility will be what they do about it.
    Signed:

    Dr. E. Lee Spence, President

    Sea Research Society (founded 1972)

    843-821-0001 or 843-832-0962

     

    Note: Spence discovered the Hunley in 1970. In at the official request of 1995 Senator McConnell and the Hunley Commission, Spence donated his rights to the wreck to the State.

     

    From: Adamson, William J STSC COMSUBLANT ,N02C [mailto:william.adamson@navy.mil]
    Sent: Tuesday, May 09, 2006 2:58 PM
    To: Cwilliams3k@MSN.com
    Subject: Alligator coin info
    Alligator Challenge Coins

     Mr. Williams
      Thank you for the assistance in spreading the word about the USS Alligator. I have enclosed link to the website page where we are selling them as well as the NMLHA website
    http://www.navyandmarine.org/alligator/alligatorcoins.htm (Coin Sales) http://www.navyandmarine.org/alligator/index.htm Page to the Alligator web site. The Main Page to the NMLHA website is  http://www.navyandmarine.org/index.htm.

       The USS Alligator was the first true submarine of the period in many ways.  The Alligator was the most technologically advanced weapon in the Union naval arsenal, incorporating technology not usually associated with the Civil War Navy: a diver’s airlock, tanks of compressed air for adjusting the attitude of the boat, a large crew of twenty men, and an air scrubbing system to remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere. It's mode of attack--electrically-detonated limpet mines placed by its diver. Such a vessel would not be seen again in the American Navy for almost forty years.  With her loss off the coast of Cape Hatters in 1863 on her way down to Charleston S.C, the mystery and mission of the  USS Alligator has eluded historians for the past 140 years. Now with new discovery of documents and the ancestors of the crew coming forward with proof of commissioning of the ship, the hunt for the USS Alligator is on!

       During the past two years research and missions off the coast of North Carolina have been spearheaded by the Office of Naval Research and development and the National Oceanographic and Atmospheric Association.  The goal of these missions has been to discover the resting place of the Alligator and if possible recover her.  The hunt for the USS Alligator has been covered by Discovery Channel Documentary as well as numerous discussion groups and conferences. The summer research program is staring up soon. If you would like more information on the USS Alligator program please visit http://www.navyandmarine.org/alligator/index.htm 

    I hope the enclosed writeup will help.
    Thanks Joe
     


    Dear George;

    Is there any place on the internet that I can see a readable
    copy of the Magnolia Cemetery map that you show on the
    following site?
     
     
     

    Photography:

    Map of magnolia cemetery - shows location of the final burial plot of the "last hunley crew"

     
     
     
    Thank You,
    Richard Byrd 
     
    TRY THIS COPY- If it is not big enough..let me know. I finally found the time to fix this page.  Thanks for the info.  If you are out of town and need some pictures of the grave sites you mention,,let me know and I can run down there and get you a few.
    George  W. Penington   Webmaster and Editor of the Hunley.com
    website and Newsletter.  I fixed the link also Thanks for the info.

    Dear Mr. Penington,
     
    Thank you very much for the Magnolia Cemetery diagram. 
    I can easily read it.
     
    I am not sure whether you are aware of it or not,
    but when I clicked on the small map of Magnolia Cemetery,
    I got a error message that "The page cannot be found". 
    I assume clicking on the small map carries you to a larger
    readable map of Magnolia Cemetery.  If this is the case,
    the link to the larger map must be broken on the following page.
     
     
    Again, I really appreciate your quick response and taking
    the time to send me the larger map.  I am trying to locate
    several Barton graves shown on "Tombstone Records of
    Magnolia Cemetery" on the following site.
     
     
    Each grave shows a B) prior to the name of the person
    and the inscription.  I have already found some Alderson
    graves which were preceded by A) in what appears to
    be "Outer Circle A" on your map, near the connection to
    Greenhill.  Since the Alderson are related to the Bartons,
    I assume that my Bartons are buried nearby, probably in
    "Gibbes Circle B".
     
    Thank You,
    Richard Byrd
     



     

     

    HISTORIC CHARLESTON

    New Recommended Sites  www.towntracker.com and www.charleston.towntracker.com  Started it with a Civil War History of Charleston including a lot of pictures "Then and Now" I will be listing the best places to stay and places to go!
    WELCOME TO TOUR HILTON HEAD
    Only 90 minutes from Charleston

     

     

    FROM THE HUNLEY STORE 

    CELEBRATING OUR FIFTH STORE YEAR  with a
    NEWSLETTER SPECIAL
    All Subscribers can have a free Collectors
    Coin by paying for the Shipping only.

     

    Charles Williams
    Williams Media


     



    The Hunley - Will She Sink Again?

    Hunley financial investigation
    The State Newspaper

    Posted on Sun, May. 14, 2006

     

    Gen. Glenn F. McConnellGen. Robert E. Lee


    The State Paper ran a series of articles about the Confederate States Submarine H L Hunley.  Enclosed is a brief summary of these articles. 

    It is recommended that each reader go to the originating site at the State Paper and read each of the full articles. You may post your comments on the State Paper site or email me and I will post them here.  Here is the link:
    http://www.thestate.com/mld/thestate/14585001.htm or click

    I WILL PUBLISH ANY RESPONSES FROM SENATOR McConnell in the next newsletter.- GWP

    When it was announced and published in this newsletter that Clemson University was going to take over the Confederate States Submarine  H L Hunley, I thought it was a glorious day. We felt that finally an institution of higher learning could study the facts and findings and present them intelligently to the community without politics and prejudice.  How mistaken we were. Its politics as usual.  McConnell is a genius at maneuvering and manipulations. I was with him in college and saw him in action. Business behind closed doors, secret deals and bargains was his style, a legitimate talent. It was even humorous sometimes what he could accomplish in student government.  He was president of the student body when I was president of the sophomore class.

    McConnell has crossed the line from what used to be humorous to what is now life crushing .The disappointment now is that Clemson was forced to agree to muzzle its professors from writing or speaking publicly on the Hunley without approval of the Hunley Commission. Hundreds of us have looked forward to the day that true facts and needed information would be forthcoming.  Getting pictures or dimensions of parts was always provided underground with promises that we would never reveal our sources.  What we felt was public information has always been closely guarded and rarely shared.

    The State paper states that McConnell can "neutralize senators who might question Hunley spending. McConnell protected other senators’ pet projects in exchange for favorable votes on Hunley issues. Crossing McConnell on Hunley funding, one lawmaker says, is not worth the scars."  Well many of us have the scars to prove it.

    It is my opinion that the Hunley , even though it is a fascinating story and I have an obvious interest after eleven years of freely and voluntarily promoting and making the public aware of her existence through 65 newsletters and the largest archival site on the web, I feel the waning interest. From thousands of daily hits to mere hundreds, the sparse visits to the Warren Lasch Center, the poor management and sales at the Hunley Gift shop is proof to me that a study needs to be done.

    The responses to the State papers articles may be some indication of the way the public feels.  It is a shame that Glenn did not respond to at least some of the allegations, hopefully he will by time the next newsletter is written.  GWP

    A $3 million Hunley exhibit in a hot tourist market has failed to attract sufficient visitors and closed.

    A Hunley replica the Burroughs & Chapin Co. Inc. built at Broadway at the Beach, one of the state's top tourist attractions, never caught on. And experts have debunked many of the claims about the Hunley's importance to submarine technology. In other words, taxpayers are expected to fund a project that may end up turning into a money pit.

    The exhibit was described as follows:  "Come and experience interactive exhibits, movies, and museum displays at the H.L. Hunley Experience in the Adventure IN Science, History & Nature building (located in Heroes Harbor at Broadway at the Beach). Learn interesting details about the men who served on board. Also, view replicas and artifacts such as a legendary gold coin which served as Dixon’s good luck charm after it saved his life by stopping a bullet from wounding his leg during the battle of Shiloh. The H.L. Hunley experience is truly a journey through early American history. "

    In January 2006 the following was announced: The year 2005 saw the closing of the H.L. Hunley Experience, a high-tech audio-visual experience within the Broadway attraction known as the Adventure in Science, History and Nature, which is designed to hold rotating exhibits such as the one that told the story of the Confederate submarine. After two years, B&C determined that the H.L. Hunley Experience had run its course in the Broadway location.

    The company is talking with proprietors of large museums and owners of historical and educational destinations who might want the exhibit.

    The exit of the H.L. Hunley Experience leaves a large space open for something new in 2006.
     

    Candidates want audit of Hunley
    Some candidates in the governor's and state treasurer's race are calling for an audit of the Hunley's finances. Other candidates in the June 13 primary stop short of calling for an audit, but most say they would support - or not object to - an audit.
    Sunday, May 28, 2006 (MyrtleBeachOnline.com)

    What the STATE PAPER found:

    • The cost of Hunley projects has risen, without public debate, to $97 million.

    • Much Hunley funding is hidden; about 85 percent is taxpayer dollars.

    • Sen. Glenn McConnell, with no apparent legal authority, acts as Hunley paymaster.

    • Clemson University stepped in just as federal grants, private donations and visitors to the lab are declining.

    • McConnell personally lobbies state agencies for money, avoiding public debate.

    How senator steers sub under radar [http://www.thestate.com/mld/thestate/14577313.htm]
    Hunley costs spiral to nearly $100 million as McConnell helps funnel money its way.

    By JOHN MONK jmonk@thestate.com
    The cost of preserving and promoting the Hunley submarine has soared to nearly $100 million  thanks largely to a powerful politician’s behind-the-scenes work to steer public money toward his pet project.

    The Hunley is one of South Carolina’s biggest financial undertakings in modern times. Not counting university expansion projects, the Hunley ranks behind only a few large road and bridge projects. It even exceeds the $62 million State House renovation in the 1990s.  more>>>>

    $42 million facility could be one of S.C.’s most expensive, least studied
    With no market study, sub museum risks sinking

    By JOHN MONK jmonk@thestate.com
    Officials who want to build a $42 million museum for the Hunley submarine in North Charleston haven’t done feasibility, site and market studies that experts say are crucial to knowing whether the project will work.

    And, if the dwindling numbers of visitors to other, smaller Hunley exhibits are any gauge, it’s possible the mostly taxpayer-supported museum might fail to draw sufficient visitors and wind up being a white elephant. more>>>>>

    Hunley key moments:

    • The H.L. Hunley was one of some 20 submarines built by the North and South during the Civil War. It was the first submarine in history to sink an enemy ship in warfare.
    • The Hunley had a Tennessee financier and namesake, Horace Hunley, and a Cincinnati-born designer, James McClintock.
    • The sub was built for two reasons: to sink Union ships and to turn a profit. Private investors who gave money for the Hunley hoped to get bounties from the Confederate government.
    • Early 1863 Hunley is built and tested in Mobile, Ala.
    • Aug. 15, 1863 Hunley arrives in Charleston at the request of Gen. P.G.T. Beauregard. He wants it to sink Union ships blockading the city.
    • Aug. 29, 1863  The Hunley sinks in Charleston Harbor. Five crewmen drown.
    • Oct. 15, 1863  The Hunley sinks again. All eight crewmen die, including financier Hunley.
    • Feb. 17, 1864  The Hunley sinks the USS Housatonic off Charleston. It is a 200-foot Union warship with a crew of 155. Five Housatonic crewmen die. The sub doesn’t return from its mission.
    • 1970  A South Carolinian, Lee Spence, apparently found the Hunley in the 1970s, locating the correct longitude and latitude. Spence pursued his claim, but nothing official came of it. His claim today is the subject of legal dispute.
    • January 1995  Researchers, including underwater adventurer and author Clive Cussler, find a metal object off Sullivan’s Island. It lies in a channel that silted over in 1880. Like the Hunley, the object is 40 feet long and 6 feet wide.
    • May 1995  Divers confirm the Hunley’s discovery under 18 feet of water and 12 feet of sand and silt. The bodies of the crewmen are suspected to still be on board.
    • Aug. 8, 2000 The 10-ton Hunley is raised, placed on a barge and moved up the Cooper River to North Charleston. A crane lifts it and swings it into a tank at a conservation facility.
    • April 17, 2004 The crewmen are buried in Charleston. SOURCES: thehunley.org; Raising the Hunley, by Brian Hicks and Schuyler Kropf; The Submarine: A History by Thomas Parrish; Lost Subs by Spencer Dunmore

    Back to the Table of Contents

    With no market study, sub museum risk...
    READERS COMMENTS

     
    The whole story of the development and funding for the project is intentionally complicated and vague. The state of South Carolina cannot afford a $100,000,000.00 white elephant. Few states can.
     When you are asked for more tax money, tuition increases at Clemson or financial promises by local governments remember this story. Avg 3.90, 10 votes


    This is a sure flop. What a waste. No tourist is going to travel to N. Charleston to see an old confederate sub. An existing museum makes sense alot more sense. Duh McConnell  Avg 3.50, 10 votes


    Another instance of "hidden" business as usual in the South Carolina legislature, without regard for benefit to, or impact upon, taxpayers... Avg 4.10, 10 votes

     If I'm going to be fleeced by the "Good 'ol Boys" I would much prefer it to be on a public historical project such as this instead of a "Bridge to Nowhere"


    Believe McConnell has a little too much power, and is apparently prone to getting his own way. Too bad his passion was not education or jobs, instead of a 150 year old rusting sub with a hate filled flag flying above it.
     

    The real reason Senator McConnell wants the Hunley in North Charleston is his confederate store is also located in North Charleston. This will only benefit him because sales at his store will increase. It's just the good old boys looking out for themselves again while our children ride on 13+ year old school bus bought second hand from Kentucky. Just so you know $100,000,000.00 dollars would have bought 1250 new school bus at a price tag of $80,000.00 dollars a bus. Put the sub in an existing building and use the money saved to benefit all of the citizens of South Carolina not just those who have a love for a country "The Confederacy" that has been dead for 141 years.
    The article indicates to build the museum the city, state and federal government will have to contribute large amounts of tax money to the museum project. Enough all ready. Tax money comes out of the pockets of the tax payer. It is not the piggy bank of politicians. The politicians who don't understand that need to be replaced and there are a lot that need to be replaced. Avg 4.83, 6 votes
    This has been a three day long attack piece. I have never seen a publication dedicate itself so entirely to the destruction of any one project.  Avg 2.76, 13 votes
    "To do it right, you have to have a state-of-the-art, world-class facility. Not only will it be a great world attraction, but it will be an asset to the taxpayers rather than a burden... This quote proves it! The man (McConnell) is a lunatic! Avg 4.25, 8 votes
    Do they really think the average Charleston tourist will go out of their way to just see the Hunley while the Aquarium, Patriot's Point, Ft. Sumter, etc are all close together?
    The Senator is more interested in playing "dress up" and feathering his nest than he is in being a good steward of public funds. It's reprehensible that citizens should be forced to pay for his hobby!! And only as a result of his position of influence. Clemson, get a backbone!
    Avg 4.33, 6 votes
    Perhaps John Courson should suggest the sub be housed at the State Museum in Columbia; in place of the existing Hunley replica. Avg 5.00, 4 votes

    Make the senators pay for their own hobbies.  Avg 5.00, 5 votes
     


    Courson isn't going to suggest anything involving the Hunley to anyone... he's too busy holding McConnell's coat-tail. I hope the Attorney General's office will request a full audit of this situation. I doubt McConnell was in this by himself, I believe he will be found to be the ring leader but I suspect that there are more legislators involved. Nobody, I repeat, nobody is going to travel to North Charleston to visit this museum and it'll be closed within two years of opening. There's only one location for this submarine... Patriot's Point. If you're into maritime history, you go to Patriot's Point, not Patriot's Point AND North Charleston (where you take your life in your hands every time you drive through that section of Charleston). This whole fiasco has been snuck through the legislature without any thought. For a bunch of brilliant, educated legislators, they sure are beginning to look stupid over this project. Avg 4.33, 6 votes
    Maybe more private dollars can be raised to take some of the burden off of South Carolina taxpayers. I'm sure more Sons of Confederate Veterans members would be willing to pitch in, but their wallets are being drained by the SCV's national leadership to pay legal fees to have their Klan lawyers at the Southern Legal Resource Center file stupid flag tee-shirt lawsuits all over the place. Raise more member money for the Hunley and less money to defend the likes of Winston McCuen!
    Avg 1.00, 2 votes

    McConnell's store is located in North Charleston. North Charleston is the selected location for the Hunley museum. North Charleston is about as far away from the traditional Charleston tourist trap as you can get in that city (wave at Patriots Point as you drive past it on you way to N. Charleston). I wonder if Glenn had a gift shop already designed into the museum for his business to move into. Does anyone else see the coincidence here? Obviously they don't down at the state house where everyone is afraid to stand up to King Glenn.
    Avg 5.00, 6 votes
    "This has been a three day long attack piece. I have never seen a publication dedicate itself so entirely to the destruction of any one project. "
    THen you don't read the newspaper very much.
    This is part of a newspaper's job - shedding light on things that are somewhat complicated that even state Senators admit they don't know all the facts.
    This is a mess at this point.
    Avg 3.66, 6 votes
    McConnell is a self serving crook. It is no wonder our state lags the nation in so many areas. Our politicians are more interested in their own pockets than what is good for our citizens. Where are the voices in the Senate that are willing to stand up to Boss McConnell? Avg 4.00, 5 votes
    I hope the voters in Senator McConnel's district will ask themselves if he is spending the taxpayer's money wisely considering all the other pressing needs our state is facing. If they don't think so then they should vote him out of office. Avg 5.00, 3 votes
    I hope the State keeps up the attack on the Hunley project until McConnell is forced to stop sucking up taxpayers money on his "special project" even if takes daily attacks for a year. If the elected officials would stick to business and quit entertaining themselves the state would have plenty of money.
    Foolish politicians at work once again. Why is it that many politicians haven't a clue. Sorry but if I'm on vacation, and seeing the sights, I am NOT going to waste my precious vacation time on a side trip to see a rusted submarine and a bunch of old fire engines. Use some brains you lack and place it in an existing museum at a cost savings to the taxpayers!
    In 1974 I suggested that the Hunley be raised and placed at Patriots Point as part of the naval and maritime exhibits that were then being planned there. As the original discoverer of the Hunley, I still think it should be at Patriots Point. That is part of why I signed over my rights to the wreck to the State when Senator McConnell asked me to do so at a meeting of the Hunley Commission on September 14, 1995. The honorable Senator has obviously forgotten the promises he made to me that day. Perhaps my efforts to cut funding to reasonable levels were not to his liking. For more information, see www.shipwrecks.com .
    Avg 3.66, 3 votes
    In my previous post I mentioned that I was the original discoverer of the Hunley and had donated the Hunley to the state at McConnell's request. The message didn't show my name. I am Dr. E. Lee Spence. The "State" does list me in the events relating to the Hunley's history. I actually found the wreck in 1970. I mapped its location and gave copies to the Corps of Engineers, the Navy and dozens of government officials. I tried for years to get permission to raise it and donate it to Patriots Point. I had suggested it be preserved in a tank of water with viewing ports for public display. With no success I finally published the Hunley's location in my 1995 book "Treasures of the Confederate Coast: The Real Rhett Butler & Other Revelations." I gave a copy to Clive Cussler's employee Ralph Wilbanks with the request that they go to my spot and verify my discovery. Wilbanks went to the same location and afterwards claimed the discovery in the name of NUMA and Cussler and the guys who were with him. Cussler was later quoted in the Charleston paper as threatening to take the $100,000 he had promised to donate to McConnell's commission and to write the check instead to McConnell's political opponent. It was immediately after Cussler's threat that McConnell started breaking all of his promises to me, even to the point of ignoring my original discovery and my donation of the Hunley. I am also V.P. of the International Diving Institute  www.InternationalDivingInstitute.com and on the Board of the American Military Museum in Charleston. McConnell has repeatedly withheld Hunley related documents that he should have disclosed under the Freedom of Information Act. My hope is they have not been destroyed.
    Avg 3.33, 3 votes
    Once again we see that John Monk has an anti-Southern agenda in the stories he writes. This Hunley series is very similar to his vendetta against Maurice Bessinger a few years ago. You ony need to see that he used a photo of McConnell in his re-enactors uniform as an attention getter. Like Lee Bandy, Monk's writing show the liberal slant of the staff at the State newspaper. Avg 1.00, 5 votes
    Sounds like a shakey project with a high risk.
    Avg 5.00, 2 votes
    Just disgusting the way McConnell is spending public money on his "hobby" while other projects that would benefit the public more are set aside for lack of money. The sad part is the fool will get voted back in no problem next election. What a waste of money. Avg 5.00, 4 votes
    Why doesnt Clemson get out of Charleston? No one wants Clemson in Charleston. Its ridiculous.
    Avg 3.25, 4 votes
    There's nothing "anti-Southern" about this coverage. As an African American Southerner, I have no problem with a portion of taxpayer money being spent on this project as it represents a pivotal point in the history of the South and the nation; however, anything funded with public dollars should be subject to public scrutiny, and THIS is the point of this series. Fiscal impropriety is not "Southern," it's absolutely wrong, as is Bessinger's racist views--which do not reflect my Southern heritage.
    Avg 5.00, 2 votes
    To the person who said nobody wants Clemson in Charleston ... thats your reaction to this article, you idiot?
    Avg 4.00, 1 vote
    UNCONSTITUTIONAL: Hunley Commission violates Separation of Powers Clause.
    One point that everyone seems to overlooking is that the Hunley Commission is actually a committee of the General Assembly which is the Legislative Branch of South Carolina's government. Even though Senator McConnell saw to it that the Commission was to assume all of the duties of the State Archaeologist and the duties of the South Carolina Institute of Archaeology & Anthropology, which are office's of the Executive Branch, the Hunley Commission's exercise of those powers has not just been handled in questionable ways it is clearly a violation of South Carolina's Constitution. Our constitution has a separation of powers clause. That clause clearly and wisely prohibits one branch of South Carolina's government taking over the duties of an office of another branch. As an attorney and South Carolina's Senator Pro Tempore, it is impossible for me to believe that McConnell is unaware of that fact. Perhaps the honorable senator simply thinks his wishes should supercede those of South Carolina's citizens. (Contributed by Dr. E. Lee Spence, original discoverer of the Hunley. Spence donated the Hunley to the state at Senator McConnell's request on September 14, 1995. See
    www.shipwrecks.com
    Avg 5.00, 2 votes
    Someone wrote that McConnell was well meaning. I disagree. I (Dr. E. Lee Spence) also believe that his bullying, threats, lies, misleading statements, broken promises, dirty dealing and ignoring of facts has hurt the Hunley project. I only wish I had gotten to know him before I agreed to donate my rights to the Hunley (I, not Cussler, was the original discoverer) when McConnell asked me to after reviewing and listening to evidence of my discovery. Had I known how McConnell can back-track and lie, I would have insisted the agreement he had me sign with the Attorney General state in writing that I would be forever credited with the discovery. McConnell has not only attacked me publicly and privately trying to destroy my credibity, it is my understanding that he was behind the Governor's refusal to reappoint my wife, Sherry Shealy Martschink, to her job as Commissioner with the South Carolina Worker's Compensation Commission, a job that she excelled at and loved. (For more on Spence and his discovery of the wreck of the Hunley, see http://www.internationaldivinginstitute.com/web%20search%20for%20Hunley%20Spence%20and%20Cussler.htm
    How senator steers sub under radar  COMMENTS:
    With our school systems in such horrible conditions my tax dollars are being used in this manner without my knowledge. What is going on? Who told or allowed Sen. McConnell to do what he is doing? When is enough really enough?
    Avg 5.00, 5 votes
    You do not even write a good article because you are so focused on smearing the Senator. Apparently you have never been chosen to receive a so called favor from the Senator so your retaliation is to spew poison. Here's a thought. How about a letter about some of Senator McConnell's positive work.
    Avg 1.00, 6 votes
    I think I gave $35 to join "Friends Of HUNDLY" and I live in Texas. SC will derive a considerable am't of money from the Hundly project from tourist visting Charlestown. As a WW11 submariner I applaud the Senators work on preserving a great advancement in underwarter warfare. Look at our great Submarine Navy today. Too much histor has been lost.Avg 1.16, 6 votes
    Speaking as Northerner, the story of the Hunley is a tale of unbelievable bravery. Two years ago we chose Charleston for our summer vacation. We timed our departure from Michigan solely based on the day and time of our visit to the Warren Lasch lab to see the Hunley. Charleston is a beautiful city with many fantastic historic sites, but the Hunley was the high point of the trip for me. I hope to visit again when the Hunley is on display in a new museum. Avg 1.00, 2 votes

    Back to the Table of Contents


    NO WONDER THE DEBT OF THIS COUNTRY IS HORRENDOUS THIS NEEDS TO BE STOPPED NOW
    Oh for Pete's sake..It's Military history!
    The Hunley absolutely should be preserved, and I'm about as "New England Yankee" as you can get.
    Avg 1.33, 3 votes


    Nice piece of journalism.
    Avg 5.00, 1 vote
    South Carolina Politics as usual!
    Avg 5.00, 2 votes
    The Senator looks real nice in that uniform! Too bad it;s not a real one,we can use all the uniformed help we can get right now. Tom
    Avg 5.00, 4 votes
    Absolutely sickening...What a waste of tax money. We indeed do have a sick society down there in South Carolina that would allow taxpayer!s dollars to surreptiously enshrine an historic artifact that should instead be funded by private bigots.
    Avg 5.00, 3 votes
    Isn't anyone noticing that not one thing positive or even moderate was said about the Hunley or McConnell in this series of stories? Why does anyone think they should just trust something because it is in print? I admit, I am a Hunley fan. I find the story fascinating. And just like a contract, if you read the fine print, the State has spent only 4% of what the article claims. But hey, I guess that is just a detail Avg 1.20, 5 votes
    His story makes want to o disgorge n this BAST*RDS head!
    Avg 5.00, 1 vote
    Even if you are a fan of the Hunley, one should be shocked at the lack of oversight regarding the funding of this state project. No one person should have this much authority over the public's money without being accountable.
    Avg 5.00, 3 votes
    The South Carolina's agreement with the Federal Government over the Hunley requires all of the royalties admissions and other monies received due to the Hunley to go to the State. Somehow McConnell has allowed the Friends of the Hunley, Inc. (which is not a State agency) to collect millions of such revenues, yet not one single dollar has gone into State coffers. Instead it has been spent without the normal government oversight. Do you think it has been spent correctly, wisely, legally? Think about it. signed: Dr. E. Lee Spence, original discoverer of the Hunley and president of the Sea Research Society www.shipwrecks.com   Avg 4.00, 4 votes
    when so many others try to destroy everything Confederate I am happy to see one man can accomplish such an undertaking. I am sure the government will go on.
    Avg 1.00, 4 votes
    This has nothing to do with destroying "everything Confederate" and has everything to do with fiscal impropriety. I'm sure you wouldn't take a similar stand had this been Sen. Robert Ford from Charleston and the proposed African American Museum, which seems as though it will never get off the ground.
  • Avg 5.00, 4 votes
  • There should be no debate on the merits of preserving a historic artifact like the Hunley. What SHOULD be questioned is how can we as a state spend this kind of money on a project without a debate of ANY kind. It's not about the Hunley, it's about the PROCESS. State troopers are short handed and are riding around in unsafe vehicles with extremely high miles and it takes 6 months of Legislative debate to get a couple of patrol classes and a hand full of new vehicles. How can we spend ANY state money on this project without the same type of discussion. It doesn't make sense no matter how you look at it. No one should have this much control in State government. If the Legislature has to debate education funding, state pay raises and police funding. Certainly, any money being allocated to a non-vital cause should be debated and approved by the people we elect to over see our tax money. Anything else is absolutely irresponsible and borders on government corruption. Avg 5.00, 3 votes
    Amazing use of tax payer money. "Creative financing" should be on the top of South Carolina" license plates. Republicans or Democrats have no reluctance to squander tax payer money and after squandering the money have no reluctance to raise our taxes.
    Avg 5.00, 2 votes
    Exciting! What an example of journalism and the Constitution at work What an expose into the halls of privelege, government and education.
    Avg 5.00, 1 vote
    Great series...looks like another ENRON in the making. The Hunley is sustained mostly by "institutionalized, systematic, and well-planned accounting fraud "which meets the criteria for an all out accounting scandal. Political scandals are discovered by the disclosure of misdeeds by trusted politicians. Such misdeeds typically involve complex methods of misusing or misdirecting funds, overstating revenues, understating expenses, overstating the value of assets or under reporting the existence of liabilities, along with as in this case - the forced cooperation of officials in other offices. We have all of that. Nothing is ever put out for bid, no-one outside the club has a chance at any of the contracts FOTH lets out. We the stockholders, excuse me, citizens of the State do not know where all the money went. The fact that McConnell is holding onto control of information by muzzling Clemson is another disappointment. I thought finally we the public can now have a look at all the information and artifacts that have been withheld from us for years without having to sue to get it. A day after the burial of the Hunley crew interest started waning, 8 out of 10 people asked reply 'What's a Hunley'. The whole project is mismanaged. Their should be a civil and criminal investigation held. $100 million is a lot to spend for a package of artifacts...maybe they ought to just put it back. George W. Penington Webmaster and Editor of The Hunley.com website and monthly newsletter.Avg 5.00, 2 votes
    I paid $10 cash to visit the Warren Lasch Conservation Lab at the Navy Base to take a tour of the Hunley. The ticket-taker gave me a little purple piece of paper with two images: a Hunley submarine image and the words "Admit One." No serial number. And so ... no accounting or cash control system. Everyone else in my group paid cash and got the same grammar-school-quality ticket. Do you think other state events or institutions, like museums, zoos, football games, etc., sell tickets printed at Kinko's with no serial numbers? I wouldn't be surprised if my $10 disappeared into someone's pocket and never made it to the Hunley bank account. This is the way Sen. McConnell handles cash. And he's going to get millions more? Crazy, man!! Avg 5.00, 4 votes
    Interesting piece. Interesting in the fact it reveals who reads The State, and who doesn't. Of course, as it's been said, "Keep your friends close, and your enemies closer" as attributed to Chinese General Sun-tzu. There's my reason.
    Of the boo-koo money poured into the public school systems, bussing, etc I'd like to see the benefit per dollar. It's simply a money pit.


    But here's something actually worth it's value, the money spent on it. And the writer chooses to attack the means of doing so.ng so.


    Let's see. Would it have occurred to Mr. Monk that had Mr. McConnell been engaging in illegal activities, uhm, I don't know, he'd be prosecuted?

    The piece and resulting comments have been interesting thus far revealing the temporal rather than the permanent appears to be the priority of those who'd read The State.Avg 2.00, 4 votes Regarding the last post: po"Let's see. Would it have occurred to Mr. Monk that had Mr. McConnell been engaging in illegal activities, uhm, I don't know, he'd be prosecuted?
    The piece and resulting comments have been interesting thus far revealing the temporal rather than the permanent appears to be the priority of those who'd read The State."


    This ponderous, scholarly-sounding blogger doesn't understand that law enforcemnts officials -- State Attorney General or local Solicitor -- are both beholden to McConnell and would never file criminal charges against him. To do so, they would have to have probable cause, determined by an investigation by SLED, the Dept. of Revenue, or a local sheriff or police department, all highly unlikely given that McConnell controls them, too. "Temporal versus permanent..." Whaaat?? Recommend you stop imitating Sartre and Kierkegaard. Take a course in writing.
    Avg 3.00, 2 votes
    Pass the pork, please.
    For those who missed the outstanding editorial in The State on May 20, here it is. Hunley illustrates why S.C. remains poor, behindIn a small, poor state with 33 public colleges spread out over 79 campuses -- that's 1.7 per county -- one university decides, pretty much on its own, to build a whole new campus all the way on the other side of the state. Without any real public debate. Just because the university wanted to.


    In a state that needs to focus every ounce of intellectual and political energy and leadership that it can muster on making us healthier, wealthier and better educated, the most powerful man in the government, and one of its most intelligent and creative, spends his time fixating over a tiny footnote of history.

    Back to the Table of Contents

    This is the short version of why South Carolina remains first on so many lists on which we want to be last and last on so many lists on which we want to be first: We dont prioritize our needs and coordinate our limited resources to address those needs.


    The example at hand is how the Confederate submarine Hunley, the bizarre obsession of Senate President Pro Tempore Glenn McConnell, became an excuse for Clemson University to erect an entire new campus.
    We are taken aback by the total amount of spending, recently calculated by The States John Monk, that has been envisioned for preserving, studying and enshrining the Hunley: Although the $6 million or so the state has spent so far isnt out of line with the millions we spend on other museums or pouring sand on eroding beaches or building soccer fields and football stadiums, most of those things are of much greater public interest. And all of them are pork -- money that could have been better spent. And we simply do not believe officials can justify spending another dime, either to help finance a museum whose financial viability has not yet been established ($7 million from the state envisioned), or to help underwrite Clemson's $35 million campus by the sea.
    But we are equally disturbed by Clemson's effort to take advantage of Mr. McConnell's preoccupation to get what it wants, and what he's not doing because of that preoccupation. The Hunley isnt just an after-hours obsession: Every moment the Senates leader spends chairing a Hunley oversight committee and making Hunley presentations and finagling with state agencies to get free favors for it is a moment he isnt spending on issues that matter to our states future.
    South Carolina has a lot of needs: We need to improve our public education system so all our kids are learning enough to become productive, taxpaying citizens. We need to repair our crumbling highways and improve our dangerous back roads and better police all our roadways. We need to overhaul our tax system so its more stable and fair and so it encourages behaviors we want to encourage and discourages behaviors we want to discourage. We need to reorganize our government so the right hand knows what the left hand is doing, and theyre working together, and theres someone the public can look to for change when its needed and hold accountable when things go wrong. (And this is a reminder of how essential it is to include our colleges in that accountability overhaul.)
    And somewhere way, way, way down on the list of things we need is a another campus for Clemson, and another shrine to the most divisive and disastrous moment in our states history isnt on the list at all. Until we realize that, its hard to see how we accomplish any of those things at the top of the list. Avg 5.00, 4 votes
    Excellent article. All I can say is shame on him. Avg 5.00, 4 votes
    Senator McConnell is the best state senator we have in South Carolina.
    Avg 1.00, 3 votes
    If McConnell is the best senator we have, they all need to be jailed. But, look at all the good he has done! I know of Catholic Priests who has done allot of good. Yet, they have harmed the helpless children entrusted to them. We tax payers are McConnell's helpless as he molests the treasury. What is a victim to do but cry for help while the smug officials and brainwashed belittle the harm. Oh, he looks so good in his uniform. You can trust him not the helpless. Should the priest of our treasury be allowed to perpetrate his evil lusts over the helpless taxpayers? I have watched McConnell and I would not trust him with my money or my child. Would you? McConnell, just as the pedophile priest, should be removed. McConnell, just as the pedophile priest, should not be allowed around that which he lusts. Do you protect the victim or the perpetrator? Highways or Dieways, The choice is yours!
    Avg 5.00, 2 votes
    A fine article, precise correct and long over due. What greatly surprises me is the inaction of The Post And Courier. I personally know that they have the facts Mr. Monk revealed and much much more. They are shirking their public duty to inform the public of the malfeasance of elected officials in such important positions of public trust. Mr. McConnell is powerful and does cower his cohorts in the budget and control to do his bidding beneath the view of the public eye. The public must be kept informed to be able to thwart these contemptible and maybe illegal machinations of self service. Mr. Leatherman and others should be careful not to approve of practices that will in the future paint them with the color of dishonesty.
    The files of the Hunley are full of abuse of the public trust, all one has to do is look at how McConnell's protégé, Mr. Lasch, as given cart blanche to rip off the public when he was given the whole cookie jar in his deal with the SPA.
    There was four years of fraud and mis-representation there, all with the support and approval of McConnell.
    The Post And Courier was very careful not to expose this and the similar inappropriate administration of The Friends Of The Hunley.
    It all STINKS, the Budget And Control guys are hereby forewarned.
    Maybe it should be funded with confederate money oh wait, it's useless just like this project.
    You can buy play Confederate money at McConnell's gift shop along with alot of other racist, Ku-Kux_Klan type of junk. McConnell is making a fortune on selling this RACIST GARBAGE to the REDNECKS HE ATTRACTS TO THE HUNLEY. And that includes the Hells Angels who drive through town twice a year for their big rallies in Myrtle Beach and Awendaw. His shop is a must-visit destination for these REDNECKS. He is the HERO OF THE REDNECK. He supports PRO-REDNECK efforts to prevent motorcycle helmet legislation in SC. Do you know anyone who likes to get dressed up like a confederate soldier, play war, get his picture took, and then drives home in his Mercedez-Benz? Where was HE during the VIETNAM WAR? THE REAL WAR. NOT "OVER THERE." He was "OVER HERE," PLAYING SOLDIER while REAL men were getting killed fighting for our country. What a low life. --Billy
    I AM OUTRAGED THAT THIS INFORMATION HAS NOT BEEN PUBLISHED IN THE POST AND COURIER. IT FURTHER CONFIRMS THEIR MIND CONTROL OF THEIR READERSHIP.
     
    THIS MONEY WASTED ON A HUNK OF RUSTED METAL SHOULD HAVE BEEN SPENT GETTING RID OF A USELESS SENATOR THAT WANTED IT PULL OFF THE OCEAN FLOOR.

    Top

     
    Tours of the Hunley are available 10 a.m.-5 p.m. Saturdays and noon-5 p.m. Sundays. Tours are not available on weekdays so that the archaeologists can continue their preservation work.

    Tickets are $12 plus a service charge and can be purchased by either calling 1-877-448-6539 or on the Internet at www.etix.com. Children under 5 are free. Tickets can be purchased in advance, and walk-up tickets are also available on a first-come, first-served basis.




    Back to the Table of Contents


     


     

    TO CANCEL RECEIVING THIS NEWSLETTER SIMPLY CLICK HERE OR SEND AN EMAIL TO: George@thehunley.com or Follow the instructions included with your e-mail.

    If you Enjoy this Newsletter and want me to keep Publishing them Please make a donation and become a Subscriber The button on the left will take you to PayPal or you can send a check to the address below.If you would like to send a check  you can send it to the address below ( Make checks out to The Hunley.com).

     Total $10.00 or more would be helpful and appreciated.

    The Hunley.com
    808 Drayton St.
    Savannah, GA 31401.


    Copyright © 1997-2006 by The HUNLEY.COM. All rights reserved. You are Free to use anything you want just let us know. Individual copyrights are included separately and reserved
    Comments and questions may be directed to webmaster: mistergwp thanks for visiting.

     

    This newsletter is a monthly publication from The Hunley.com...
    808 Drayton St.
    Savannah, GA 31401.
    Phone: 912-596-2192


     

    Hit Counter